MGB & GT Forum
I'm giving up ...........
Posted by Red Guy
|
Dwight
Dwight McCullough
Ham Lake, MN, USA
Sign in to contact
1959 Austin-Healey Sprite "SPRAAT"
1974 MG MGB "THE 'B" 1975 MG MGB "Da ' B" 1979 MG MGB Limited Edition (LE) "N.A." |
Apr 9, 2024 09:08 AM
Joined 17 years ago
1,898 Posts
|
|
|
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 9, 2024 11:30 AM
Joined 13 years ago
276 Posts
|
******** UPDATE*********
So, I have checked the valve movement, pulled the plugs and rolled the engine over, watched and measured, everything is moving fine.
I turned to the carbs; See pictures for what I found ............................................
So, I have checked the valve movement, pulled the plugs and rolled the engine over, watched and measured, everything is moving fine.
I turned to the carbs; See pictures for what I found ............................................
Attachments:
|
|
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 9, 2024 11:32 AM
Joined 13 years ago
276 Posts
|
|
Apr 9, 2024 01:57 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 19 years ago
4,913 Posts
|
|
Since the front carb feeds cylinders 1 & 2, and the rear carb feeds 3 & 4, I don't think your lack of firing on 1 & 4 are a carb issue.
I think I'd be looking closer at the distributor. Has something happened to the cap would be my first question. A coolant leak from the heater valve could cause shorting out inside the cap on 1 and 4.
If you have an old dist. cap put it on and see it solves the problem. And just as a double safety replace the rotor as well.
BH
I think I'd be looking closer at the distributor. Has something happened to the cap would be my first question. A coolant leak from the heater valve could cause shorting out inside the cap on 1 and 4.
If you have an old dist. cap put it on and see it solves the problem. And just as a double safety replace the rotor as well.
BH
|
smokey w
Juri P
|
Apr 9, 2024 03:07 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 5 years ago
2,511 Posts
|
The difference in the damper piston positions could possibly be a problem. When you balance the carbs at idle, the pistons are inactive. When you press the throttle, the piston on the left will encounter resistance later than the one on the right, so when you accelerate, the carbs are no longer balanced. I believe those pistons have to be identical to achieve smooth acceleration.
In reply to # 4782952 by Red Guy
******** UPDATE*********
So, I have checked the valve movement, pulled the plugs and rolled the engine over, watched and measured, everything is moving fine.
I turned to the carbs; See pictures for what I found ............................................
So, I have checked the valve movement, pulled the plugs and rolled the engine over, watched and measured, everything is moving fine.
I turned to the carbs; See pictures for what I found ............................................
|
|
Apr 9, 2024 03:26 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 12 years ago
29,281 Posts
|
Recheck your firing order. " 1,3,4,2, CCW "Counterclockwise".
IN ALL SUBJECTS.: For those who believe, no proof is needed. For those who don’t believe, no proof is possible.
"Strive for perfection in everything. Take the best that exists and make it better. If it doesn't exist, create it. Accept nothing nearly right or good enough"
Sir Henry Royce
co-founder of Rolls-Royce .
"I take no credit for my own, of another man's fame".
Joe Baba 2021
In reply to # 4782469 by Red Guy
Tried everything. Still bogging and popping through the rear carb. Rebuilt Twin SUs.
Car was running great, smooth, good power, easy starting, then suddenly ............ bogging and popping through the rear carb.
All new ignition parts including the dizzy. (Because the original Diz was a mess.)
Ignition timing spot on.
Valve timing spot on.
Compression test = excellent.
Car starts and idles great but can't touch the gas.
I'm about to pull the plugs and have a look.
What am I missing ???
Car was running great, smooth, good power, easy starting, then suddenly ............ bogging and popping through the rear carb.
All new ignition parts including the dizzy. (Because the original Diz was a mess.)
Ignition timing spot on.
Valve timing spot on.
Compression test = excellent.
Car starts and idles great but can't touch the gas.
I'm about to pull the plugs and have a look.
What am I missing ???
IN ALL SUBJECTS.: For those who believe, no proof is needed. For those who don’t believe, no proof is possible.
"Strive for perfection in everything. Take the best that exists and make it better. If it doesn't exist, create it. Accept nothing nearly right or good enough"
Sir Henry Royce
co-founder of Rolls-Royce .
"I take no credit for my own, of another man's fame".
Joe Baba 2021
Member Services:
|
Arizona Shorty
G M
P, A, Albania
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 9, 2024 03:40 PM
Joined 2 years ago
4,926 Posts
|
Cylinder #1 and #4 have something in common. They fire 180 degrees from each other. Clean plugs suggest no combustion event, but do not show lack of spark necessarily. If the spark event is 180* out of synch, it would essentially be running on two cylinders, in your case, 3 and 4. #1 and #4 could be firing on the wrong stroke, and they would just be deadheading.
I would start at the beginning with the distributor. Set the engine to #1 TDC, such that the #1 valves are both closed, verified by actually looking at them rather than looking at timing marks. Then reset the distributor with the rotor pointing at #1 plug wire, which is commonly at about the one o'clock position. Then verify firing order counterclockwise from #1. These are the steps to take to set a new distributor. After that, you can set your timing.
I can't see a #1 and #4 failure attributable to the points or coil or condenser. Such failures would be more randomized, or more across the board, not isolated to two cylinders. Nor is it lack of fuel, since those two cylinders are served by different carbs. Whether you should have matching carb parts is a good question, but not likely to be your issue here.
GMc
I would start at the beginning with the distributor. Set the engine to #1 TDC, such that the #1 valves are both closed, verified by actually looking at them rather than looking at timing marks. Then reset the distributor with the rotor pointing at #1 plug wire, which is commonly at about the one o'clock position. Then verify firing order counterclockwise from #1. These are the steps to take to set a new distributor. After that, you can set your timing.
I can't see a #1 and #4 failure attributable to the points or coil or condenser. Such failures would be more randomized, or more across the board, not isolated to two cylinders. Nor is it lack of fuel, since those two cylinders are served by different carbs. Whether you should have matching carb parts is a good question, but not likely to be your issue here.
GMc
|
|
Apr 9, 2024 03:55 PM
Joined 7 years ago
155 Posts
|
|
smokey w
Juri P
|
Apr 9, 2024 04:05 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 5 years ago
2,511 Posts
|
Jeff Schlemmer's site Advanced Distributors has an excellent write-up on setting up a disturbed distibutor. I always follow his procedure, and use a compression gauge to find TDC on the compression stroke on #1, and an in-line spark sensor to determine when the spark occurs. You have to be certain you're on the compression stroke when you set the initial timing.
|
Apr 9, 2024 04:35 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 19 years ago
4,913 Posts
|
|
x2000
Pay attention to the evidence. 1 and 4 aren't firing. If they were the plugs wouldn't look like they were right out of the box. Why? Look for the reason and you'll find your problem. It is either no fuel which is unlikely given the nature of a front and rear carbs or no spark. I'd be checking out the spark coming to 1 and 4. Put a spark tester on those two plugs or plug wires. As others have said are you 100% certain you have the correct firing order on the plug wires? 1,3,4,2 CCW (probably not the problem as it was a sudden onset issue). Did you look at the distributor cap for flaws? Did you recently have a leaking heater valve?
BH
Pay attention to the evidence. 1 and 4 aren't firing. If they were the plugs wouldn't look like they were right out of the box. Why? Look for the reason and you'll find your problem. It is either no fuel which is unlikely given the nature of a front and rear carbs or no spark. I'd be checking out the spark coming to 1 and 4. Put a spark tester on those two plugs or plug wires. As others have said are you 100% certain you have the correct firing order on the plug wires? 1,3,4,2 CCW (probably not the problem as it was a sudden onset issue). Did you look at the distributor cap for flaws? Did you recently have a leaking heater valve?
BH
In reply to # 4783029 by Arizona Shorty
Cylinder #1 and #4 have something in common. They fire 180 degrees from each other. Clean plugs suggest no combustion event, but do not show lack of spark necessarily. If the spark event is 180* out of synch, it would essentially be running on two cylinders, in your case, 3 and 4. #1 and #4 could be firing on the wrong stroke, and they would just be deadheading.
I would start at the beginning with the distributor. Set the engine to #1 TDC, such that the #1 valves are both closed, verified by actually looking at them rather than looking at timing marks. Then reset the distributor with the rotor pointing at #1 plug wire, which is commonly at about the one o'clock position. Then verify firing order counterclockwise from #1. These are the steps to take to set a new distributor. After that, you can set your timing.
I can't see a #1 and #4 failure attributable to the points or coil or condenser. Such failures would be more randomized, or more across the board, not isolated to two cylinders. Nor is it lack of fuel, since those two cylinders are served by different carbs. Whether you should have matching carb parts is a good question, but not likely to be your issue here.
GMc
I would start at the beginning with the distributor. Set the engine to #1 TDC, such that the #1 valves are both closed, verified by actually looking at them rather than looking at timing marks. Then reset the distributor with the rotor pointing at #1 plug wire, which is commonly at about the one o'clock position. Then verify firing order counterclockwise from #1. These are the steps to take to set a new distributor. After that, you can set your timing.
I can't see a #1 and #4 failure attributable to the points or coil or condenser. Such failures would be more randomized, or more across the board, not isolated to two cylinders. Nor is it lack of fuel, since those two cylinders are served by different carbs. Whether you should have matching carb parts is a good question, but not likely to be your issue here.
GMc
|
Ian Williams
Ian W
Chipping Longjourney, Toofarupnorth, UK
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 10, 2024 03:27 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 10 years ago
4,926 Posts
|
Unscrew the brass caps on the SU carbs and try the bent wire test to confirm if both pistons are lifting together.
In reply to # 4783023 by oleanderjoe
Recheck your firing order. " 1,3,4,2, CCW "Counterclockwise".
In reply to # 4782469 by Red Guy
Tried everything. Still bogging and popping through the rear carb. Rebuilt Twin SUs.
Car was running great, smooth, good power, easy starting, then suddenly ............ bogging and popping through the rear carb.
All new ignition parts including the dizzy. (Because the original Diz was a mess.)
Ignition timing spot on.
Valve timing spot on.
Compression test = excellent.
Car starts and idles great but can't touch the gas.
I'm about to pull the plugs and have a look.
What am I missing ???
Car was running great, smooth, good power, easy starting, then suddenly ............ bogging and popping through the rear carb.
All new ignition parts including the dizzy. (Because the original Diz was a mess.)
Ignition timing spot on.
Valve timing spot on.
Compression test = excellent.
Car starts and idles great but can't touch the gas.
I'm about to pull the plugs and have a look.
What am I missing ???
|
Ian Williams
Ian W
Chipping Longjourney, Toofarupnorth, UK
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 10, 2024 03:29 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 10 years ago
4,926 Posts
|
|
Jim Blackwood
* BlownMGB-V8
Gunpowder Rd, Florence, KY, USA
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 10, 2024 08:47 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 19 years ago
9,565 Posts
|
|
|
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 10, 2024 01:02 PM
Joined 13 years ago
276 Posts
|
UPDATE ..............................
So I'm doing the "Twist" test and I feel that one of the pistons drops about halfway and stops. If I spin the piston in the dome I can feel it rubbing against the wall in one spot. (See picture) You can see in the pic, a dark spot on the dome wall. I took a piece of 1200 wet sandpaper and cleaned it up. Tested the piston again and still felt the rub. Checked the piston for damage or rubbing, none found. As for the test, I cannot get a close match on either dome.
So I'm doing the "Twist" test and I feel that one of the pistons drops about halfway and stops. If I spin the piston in the dome I can feel it rubbing against the wall in one spot. (See picture) You can see in the pic, a dark spot on the dome wall. I took a piece of 1200 wet sandpaper and cleaned it up. Tested the piston again and still felt the rub. Checked the piston for damage or rubbing, none found. As for the test, I cannot get a close match on either dome.
|
|
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 10, 2024 01:14 PM
Joined 13 years ago
276 Posts
|
Having trouble posting or changing forum settings?
Read the Forum Help (FAQ) or click Contact Support at the bottom of the page.


















![20240410_133337[1].jpg](https://www.mgexp.com/phile/1/805622/20240410_133337_1_.jpg)

