MGB & GT Forum
Speedometer reading fast with overdrive gearbox
Posted by ajbelfair
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 21, 2024 08:03 PM
Joined 2 years ago
6 Posts
|
1969 MGB GT, non overdrive car with black label overdrive gearbox from a 1973 UK MGB. 1280 TPM speedometer.
I installed the overdrive gearbox this winter. I had previously removed the angle drives at both ends after one broke and put in an overdrive speedometer cable instead. Following the gearbox swap, I had to reroute the cable through the firewall on the driver side instead of the passenger footwell where it was previously. Not paying attention, I put the speedometer back in the dash putting the cable at an extreme 90 degree turn near the speedometer end. Predictably, the cable broke after a few miles. Ordered a new cable, rerouted it with softer bends, and now my speedometer reads fast by about 10 mph, or reads roughly 60 mph when my GPS speedometer reads 48-49 mph.
My question is what could be causing the speedometer to read high. Could there be a mismatch in drive/driven gears in the gearbox? Did the cable break possibly cause damage to the speedometer? Something with the new cable? Was there a TPM difference between US and UK gearboxes? Any help is appreciated.
1969 MGB GT
I installed the overdrive gearbox this winter. I had previously removed the angle drives at both ends after one broke and put in an overdrive speedometer cable instead. Following the gearbox swap, I had to reroute the cable through the firewall on the driver side instead of the passenger footwell where it was previously. Not paying attention, I put the speedometer back in the dash putting the cable at an extreme 90 degree turn near the speedometer end. Predictably, the cable broke after a few miles. Ordered a new cable, rerouted it with softer bends, and now my speedometer reads fast by about 10 mph, or reads roughly 60 mph when my GPS speedometer reads 48-49 mph.
My question is what could be causing the speedometer to read high. Could there be a mismatch in drive/driven gears in the gearbox? Did the cable break possibly cause damage to the speedometer? Something with the new cable? Was there a TPM difference between US and UK gearboxes? Any help is appreciated.
1969 MGB GT
britcarnut
Don Stewart
Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 21, 2024 08:14 PM
Joined 7 years ago
29 Posts
|
The overdrive transmission needs a different TPM speedometer than the standard 4 speed trans. I made the same change to an overdrive transmission on my '74 MGB GT. Others on here will probably chime in with the different speedometer part numbers and which TPM you need. I found overdrive speedometers hard to find. There are/have been shops that can modify your existing speedometer, but the cost is approaching or exceeding the cost of a new or reconditioned one. I was not looking for originality, as my car is a driver, not a show car. I solved the problem by installing a GPS speedometer from Speedhut. There was also a thread on here recently where someone 3-D printed a gear reduction drive for the speedometer to solve the problem.
Don
Don
Apr 21, 2024 09:52 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 8 years ago
6,258 Posts
|
From the Library:
1968 through 1974 (chrome bumper)
Laycock Type LH OD
Rectangular shaped access cover
Oval clutch fork boot
Dipstick (for checking oil)
Black label on the OD solenoid cover stamped "22/61972"
1280 TPM for OD and non-OD
Speedometer drive gear (on the mainshaft) is blue
Speedometer driven gear (on removable drive housing) is white with 21 teeth
OD on 3rd and 4th gears
I was addicted to the hokey pokey but I turned myself around.
prop-a-gan-da: When a British person takes a close look at something
1968 through 1974 (chrome bumper)
Laycock Type LH OD
Rectangular shaped access cover
Oval clutch fork boot
Dipstick (for checking oil)
Black label on the OD solenoid cover stamped "22/61972"
1280 TPM for OD and non-OD
Speedometer drive gear (on the mainshaft) is blue
Speedometer driven gear (on removable drive housing) is white with 21 teeth
OD on 3rd and 4th gears
I was addicted to the hokey pokey but I turned myself around.
prop-a-gan-da: When a British person takes a close look at something
dickmoritz
Dick Moritz
Philly 'burbs, PA, USA
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 22, 2024 05:50 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 14 years ago
26,292 Posts
|
The overdrive transmission needs a different TPM speedometer than the standard 4 speed trans.
Not necessarily. Black label/top fill gearboxes, overdrive or not, came from the factory with 1280 TPM speedo gears; blue label/side fill boxes came with 1000 TPM gears. These gears can be changed over the years, but must be changed in pairs; you can't just change the externally-accessible driven gear. You must also change the internal drive gear. Overdrives use different speedo gears from non-overdrives.
Usually the 1280 gears are white; the 1000 gears red. If your gearbox has the wrong gears you'll see a speedometer and odometer error of about 28 percent. You can confirm the colors by removing the driven gear and the steel "bearing" that retains it, but oil will run out. You can minimize oil loss if you raise the rear end of the car.
Changing the internal speedo drive gear requires engine out and overdrive apart...
Using 1000 gears with a 1280 speedo will result in a lower speedometer reading. Similarly, switching to larger diameter rear tires, including 15 inch tires, will result in a lower speedometer reading.The OP's issue is likely within the speedometer.
Dick
Errabundi Saepe, Semper Certi
(Often wrong, but always certain)
Not necessarily. Black label/top fill gearboxes, overdrive or not, came from the factory with 1280 TPM speedo gears; blue label/side fill boxes came with 1000 TPM gears. These gears can be changed over the years, but must be changed in pairs; you can't just change the externally-accessible driven gear. You must also change the internal drive gear. Overdrives use different speedo gears from non-overdrives.
Usually the 1280 gears are white; the 1000 gears red. If your gearbox has the wrong gears you'll see a speedometer and odometer error of about 28 percent. You can confirm the colors by removing the driven gear and the steel "bearing" that retains it, but oil will run out. You can minimize oil loss if you raise the rear end of the car.
Changing the internal speedo drive gear requires engine out and overdrive apart...
Using 1000 gears with a 1280 speedo will result in a lower speedometer reading. Similarly, switching to larger diameter rear tires, including 15 inch tires, will result in a lower speedometer reading.The OP's issue is likely within the speedometer.
Dick
In reply to # 4787786 by britcarnut
The overdrive transmission needs a different TPM speedometer than the standard 4 speed trans. I made the same change to an overdrive transmission on my '74 MGB GT. Others on here will probably chime in with the different speedometer part numbers and which TPM you need. I found overdrive speedometers hard to find. There are/have been shops that can modify your existing speedometer, but the cost is approaching or exceeding the cost of a new or reconditioned one. I was not looking for originality, as my car is a driver, not a show car. I solved the problem by installing a GPS speedometer from Speedhut. There was also a thread on here recently where someone 3-D printed a gear reduction drive for the speedometer to solve the problem.
Don
Don
Errabundi Saepe, Semper Certi
(Often wrong, but always certain)
bloomz thanked dickmoritz for this post
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 22, 2024 04:05 PM
Joined 2 years ago
6 Posts
|
Thanks, Dick. You’ve confirmed my suspicions and provided some valuable information.
I did some speed comparisons at 25, 45 and 60 mph according to a GPS speedometer app. The car’s speedometer read 18% higher on average. Not close to the 28% difference you mentioned with the 1000 TPM blue label gears. That seems to eliminate that possibility.
It’s worth mentioning that I have been 185/70/14 tires on the car. I also have the SN-5227/06 speedometer.
Would I be correct in thinking that a 1280 TPM speedometer is the same in function as another, regardless of whether or not it was originally fitted to an overdrive car or not? Looks like I’m on the hunt for another speedometer or having mine repaired.
1969 MGB GT
I did some speed comparisons at 25, 45 and 60 mph according to a GPS speedometer app. The car’s speedometer read 18% higher on average. Not close to the 28% difference you mentioned with the 1000 TPM blue label gears. That seems to eliminate that possibility.
It’s worth mentioning that I have been 185/70/14 tires on the car. I also have the SN-5227/06 speedometer.
Would I be correct in thinking that a 1280 TPM speedometer is the same in function as another, regardless of whether or not it was originally fitted to an overdrive car or not? Looks like I’m on the hunt for another speedometer or having mine repaired.
In reply to # 4787860 by dickmoritz
The overdrive transmission needs a different TPM speedometer than the standard 4 speed trans.
Not necessarily. Black label/top fill gearboxes, overdrive or not, came from the factory with 1280 TPM speedo gears; blue label/side fill boxes came with 1000 TPM gears. These gears can be changed over the years, but must be changed in pairs; you can't just change the externally-accessible driven gear. You must also change the internal drive gear. Overdrives use different speedo gears from non-overdrives.
Usually the 1280 gears are white; the 1000 gears red. If your gearbox has the wrong gears you'll see a speedometer and odometer error of about 28 percent. You can confirm the colors by removing the driven gear and the steel "bearing" that retains it, but oil will run out. You can minimize oil loss if you raise the rear end of the car.
Changing the internal speedo drive gear requires engine out and overdrive apart...
Using 1000 gears with a 1280 speedo will result in a lower speedometer reading. Similarly, switching to larger diameter rear tires, including 15 inch tires, will result in a lower speedometer reading.The OP's issue is likely within the speedometer.
Dick
Not necessarily. Black label/top fill gearboxes, overdrive or not, came from the factory with 1280 TPM speedo gears; blue label/side fill boxes came with 1000 TPM gears. These gears can be changed over the years, but must be changed in pairs; you can't just change the externally-accessible driven gear. You must also change the internal drive gear. Overdrives use different speedo gears from non-overdrives.
Usually the 1280 gears are white; the 1000 gears red. If your gearbox has the wrong gears you'll see a speedometer and odometer error of about 28 percent. You can confirm the colors by removing the driven gear and the steel "bearing" that retains it, but oil will run out. You can minimize oil loss if you raise the rear end of the car.
Changing the internal speedo drive gear requires engine out and overdrive apart...
Using 1000 gears with a 1280 speedo will result in a lower speedometer reading. Similarly, switching to larger diameter rear tires, including 15 inch tires, will result in a lower speedometer reading.The OP's issue is likely within the speedometer.
Dick
1969 MGB GT
dickmoritz
Dick Moritz
Philly 'burbs, PA, USA
Sign in to contact
|
Apr 22, 2024 04:55 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 14 years ago
26,292 Posts
|
Chrome bumper cars from 1968 on all used a 1280 speedometer...
Dick
Errabundi Saepe, Semper Certi
(Often wrong, but always certain)
Dick
In reply to # 4788112 by ajbelfair
Thanks, Dick. You’ve confirmed my suspicions and provided some valuable information.
I did some speed comparisons at 25, 45 and 60 mph according to a GPS speedometer app. The car’s speedometer read 18% higher on average. Not close to the 28% difference you mentioned with the 1000 TPM blue label gears. That seems to eliminate that possibility.
It’s worth mentioning that I have been 185/70/14 tires on the car. I also have the SN-5227/06 speedometer.
Would I be correct in thinking that a 1280 TPM speedometer is the same in function as another, regardless of whether or not it was originally fitted to an overdrive car or not? Looks like I’m on the hunt for another speedometer or having mine repaired.
I did some speed comparisons at 25, 45 and 60 mph according to a GPS speedometer app. The car’s speedometer read 18% higher on average. Not close to the 28% difference you mentioned with the 1000 TPM blue label gears. That seems to eliminate that possibility.
It’s worth mentioning that I have been 185/70/14 tires on the car. I also have the SN-5227/06 speedometer.
Would I be correct in thinking that a 1280 TPM speedometer is the same in function as another, regardless of whether or not it was originally fitted to an overdrive car or not? Looks like I’m on the hunt for another speedometer or having mine repaired.
In reply to # 4787860 by dickmoritz
The overdrive transmission needs a different TPM speedometer than the standard 4 speed trans.
Not necessarily. Black label/top fill gearboxes, overdrive or not, came from the factory with 1280 TPM speedo gears; blue label/side fill boxes came with 1000 TPM gears. These gears can be changed over the years, but must be changed in pairs; you can't just change the externally-accessible driven gear. You must also change the internal drive gear. Overdrives use different speedo gears from non-overdrives.
Usually the 1280 gears are white; the 1000 gears red. If your gearbox has the wrong gears you'll see a speedometer and odometer error of about 28 percent. You can confirm the colors by removing the driven gear and the steel "bearing" that retains it, but oil will run out. You can minimize oil loss if you raise the rear end of the car.
Changing the internal speedo drive gear requires engine out and overdrive apart...
Using 1000 gears with a 1280 speedo will result in a lower speedometer reading. Similarly, switching to larger diameter rear tires, including 15 inch tires, will result in a lower speedometer reading.The OP's issue is likely within the speedometer.
Dick
Not necessarily. Black label/top fill gearboxes, overdrive or not, came from the factory with 1280 TPM speedo gears; blue label/side fill boxes came with 1000 TPM gears. These gears can be changed over the years, but must be changed in pairs; you can't just change the externally-accessible driven gear. You must also change the internal drive gear. Overdrives use different speedo gears from non-overdrives.
Usually the 1280 gears are white; the 1000 gears red. If your gearbox has the wrong gears you'll see a speedometer and odometer error of about 28 percent. You can confirm the colors by removing the driven gear and the steel "bearing" that retains it, but oil will run out. You can minimize oil loss if you raise the rear end of the car.
Changing the internal speedo drive gear requires engine out and overdrive apart...
Using 1000 gears with a 1280 speedo will result in a lower speedometer reading. Similarly, switching to larger diameter rear tires, including 15 inch tires, will result in a lower speedometer reading.The OP's issue is likely within the speedometer.
Dick
Errabundi Saepe, Semper Certi
(Often wrong, but always certain)
Forums
Having trouble posting or changing forum settings?
Read the Forum Help (FAQ) or contact the webmaster