MG Midget Forum
MG Midget Offset Trunnion & Negative Camber
Posted by ozhealey
ozhealey
Tony P
|
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 11, 2024 08:44 AM
Joined 7 years ago
2 Posts
|
Hi Team,
I note a few threads regarding this issue over the years, and I understand the concern some have with the Peter May offset trunnions for road cars noting they have solid brass or bronze bushes which a lot of people indicate are quite harsh on the ride.
However what I have not seen anyone consider or suggest is simply changing the bush in the Peter May Trunnion. Perhaps this cant be done?
Essentially, I only want the trunnions to help me build a small amount of negative camber, so why couldn’t you just use the Peter May Trunnion but change the bushes to rubber or poly? You get the same offset (longer body than the standard Trunnion) to introduce the negative camber but then have a softer ride?
Thank you for any advice in advance.
Regards Tony
I note a few threads regarding this issue over the years, and I understand the concern some have with the Peter May offset trunnions for road cars noting they have solid brass or bronze bushes which a lot of people indicate are quite harsh on the ride.
However what I have not seen anyone consider or suggest is simply changing the bush in the Peter May Trunnion. Perhaps this cant be done?
Essentially, I only want the trunnions to help me build a small amount of negative camber, so why couldn’t you just use the Peter May Trunnion but change the bushes to rubber or poly? You get the same offset (longer body than the standard Trunnion) to introduce the negative camber but then have a softer ride?
Thank you for any advice in advance.
Regards Tony
Wellkevi01
Kevin Wells
|
Apr 11, 2024 09:14 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 2 years ago
202 Posts
|
Apr 11, 2024 10:29 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 15 years ago
9,787 Posts
|
In answer to your question, it is my understanding the Peter May doesn't allow use of them (it is solid, using no bushes at all).
By the way, regarding using spacers under the front shocks, unfortunately, I tried it and then measured the alignment and found almost no benefit at all, because of the angle of the mounting surface. Neat sounding idea but only a small angle change after adding very tall spacers, so I put it back.
In the end I bought a pair of these from a machinist in Australia (see attached for details), which allow use of bushings to maintain ride quality.
By the way, regarding using spacers under the front shocks, unfortunately, I tried it and then measured the alignment and found almost no benefit at all, because of the angle of the mounting surface. Neat sounding idea but only a small angle change after adding very tall spacers, so I put it back.
In the end I bought a pair of these from a machinist in Australia (see attached for details), which allow use of bushings to maintain ride quality.
Attachments:
Neg Camber Trunions from Aus.pdf 1.14 MB
AN5L8016
Mark Haynes
|
Apr 11, 2024 02:45 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 11 years ago
1,455 Posts
|
1974MGMidget
Jack Orkin
|
Apr 11, 2024 03:13 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 17 years ago
2,810 Posts
|
ozhealey
Tony P
|
Topic Creator (OP)
Apr 11, 2024 06:53 PM
Joined 7 years ago
2 Posts
|
Thank you for the responses.
Kevin: I tried that, but as indicated by others the shift is very small and I like the idea of around 1 "ish" degrees of neg camber.
Norm: I have included a picture below of the Peter May trunnion to show that the bush is separate to the trunnion and is solid brass. While you mention Peter May does not allow the change, if the brass ones come out and "if" the poly or rubber ones fit then I dont see why someone could not do it. Regardless, your piece about the Australian Bugeye person is GOLD, especially noting I'm in Australia. So I will follow up with them to get a set and use the poly bushes in those. Thank you!!
Norm, Jack: I used the offset bushes in my big Healey and they do indeed hold position by simply the process of tightening the nut which compresses the bushes and they dont move (or didnt for the years I had them in there). Only issue was the shift was again very minor and only allowed the Healey to go from standard (1 degree positive) to neutral. So the solution in that car was to use lever arm shocks with slightly shorter arms which achieved 1 degree negative camber and then the offset trunnions allowed me to adjust to get exactly the same camber in both wheels.
Regards Tony
Kevin: I tried that, but as indicated by others the shift is very small and I like the idea of around 1 "ish" degrees of neg camber.
Norm: I have included a picture below of the Peter May trunnion to show that the bush is separate to the trunnion and is solid brass. While you mention Peter May does not allow the change, if the brass ones come out and "if" the poly or rubber ones fit then I dont see why someone could not do it. Regardless, your piece about the Australian Bugeye person is GOLD, especially noting I'm in Australia. So I will follow up with them to get a set and use the poly bushes in those. Thank you!!
Norm, Jack: I used the offset bushes in my big Healey and they do indeed hold position by simply the process of tightening the nut which compresses the bushes and they dont move (or didnt for the years I had them in there). Only issue was the shift was again very minor and only allowed the Healey to go from standard (1 degree positive) to neutral. So the solution in that car was to use lever arm shocks with slightly shorter arms which achieved 1 degree negative camber and then the offset trunnions allowed me to adjust to get exactly the same camber in both wheels.
Regards Tony
1974MGMidget thanked ozhealey for this post
Apr 11, 2024 07:58 PM
Top Contributor
Joined 12 years ago
14,687 Posts
|
I have offset bushings on my vintage race Bugeye. They were installed about 1990 and haven't moved yet. Fingers crossed.
In reply to # 4783796 by 1974MGMidget
Mark, have you checked them to see if they have rotated? I don't understand what keeps them from moving. Are they just a tight fit when you tighten the upper bolt and the friction keeps them from moving?
1974MGMidget thanked refisk for this post
Apr 12, 2024 06:04 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 15 years ago
9,787 Posts
|
In reply to # 4783895 by ozhealey
Norm: I have included a picture below of the Peter May trunnion to show that the bush is separate to the trunnion and is solid brass. While you mention Peter May does not allow the change, if the brass ones come out and "if" the poly or rubber ones fit then I dont see why someone could not do it. Regardless, your piece about the Australian Bugeye person is GOLD, especially noting I'm in Australia. So I will follow up with them to get a set and use the poly bushes in those. Thank you!!
Regards Tony
Regards Tony
Regarding the Peter May, take a close look at the size of the sintered bronze bushings it uses, and compare that with the diameter of the hole required for the rubber (or poly) bushes, visible in the Bugeye Barn option. The hole in the Peter May is simply not large enough to accept them.
The difference between the Peter May negative camber top trunion and the Bugeye Barn negative camber top trunion is the amount of machining necessary to provide the room for those large sized bushings. Since Peter May is for racing they saved time (and weight) by making it a simple shape, and too small to accept the stock bushings.
Norm
AN5L8016
Mark Haynes
|
Apr 12, 2024 10:40 AM
Top Contributor
Joined 11 years ago
1,455 Posts
|
In reply to a post by 74mgmidget
Mark, have you checked them to see if they have rotated? I don't understand what keeps them from moving. Are they just a tight fit when you tighten the upper bolt and the friction keeps them from moving?
Yes and Yes. The bushings are enough oversize that the compression keeps them in place even under hard usage.'58 Bugeye
'05 Mini Cooper S
1974MGMidget thanked AN5L8016 for this post
Forums
Having trouble posting or changing forum settings?
Read the Forum Help (FAQ) or contact the webmaster