MG-2013 is only 57 days away! · Corvallis, OR · July 17–21, 2013 · Visit MG-2013.com or the MG-2013 Forum for more info

MGB & GT Forum

Welcome! Sign In Register
Please Sign In or Register to Search

just got a new mgb.......and now it's broken

Posted by joem 
Shiprobo Avatar
David Robinson
Sydney, Australia   aus
1967 MG MGB "Nigel"
Hi Joseph,

I must admit to not being an expert on these cars, but your problem sounds like an issue I have had at times with my '67. Basically these cars need three things to run, air, spark and fuel, take anyone away and you will have a problem. Now I am focusing on these because you state that the car has been running and that when running an at idle you need to keep the revs up or it stalls. In my car I have found that dirty air cleaner elements can be an issue. You haven't said what type of carb you are running, however try removing the air cleaner and then starting - if that makes a difference then replace the air cleaner elements with new ones (not expensive) and see how you go - not a big job at all. If the car has been sitting around and there has been some moisture in the air, then the air cleaners can get damp, collect dust and become choked. In my car I have had the problem simply stop the car as I drive along! Soon as I replace the filters I get better airflow, better performance and better idle.

Hope this gives you another thing to try! Whatever you do though don't give up. When I got my MG a few years ago, I had no idea how to even change oil, now I have no problem taking the engine out and doing all my own maintenance. These are great cars to learn on, very forgiving!!

Cheers,

David,
Sydney, Australia

. You can hide this ad & support this site by upgrading to a Gold Membership ~ click here for more info.
tomkatb Avatar
Larry Baygents
Dayton, Ohio, USA   usa
1963 MG MGB
If the car has been sitting a while put your battery charger on it. If voltage is too low it interferes with starting.

Charge it overnight.

If the starter was changed recently it is not likely the issue.

I would first push the car a bit to get a new location on the ring gear to try.

larry



L.W.(Larry)Baygents
63B
77 Spit
80MGBLE Avatar
Jim S.
NH, USA   usa
1980 MG MGB
Looked like you were getting ready to start a small plane. Stop, sell that car and move on. Just looking at the starter wiring set up tells me it is not worth going any further. $800 will turn into $8,000 before you blink your eye and then you'll say "Hey I could have bought a really nice 1977 MGB for $4,000."

. You can hide this ad & support this site by upgrading to a Gold Membership ~ click here for more info.
BumbleB74 Avatar
William Milholen
Tidewater VA, USA   usa
That is a little exaggerated Jim.........

Sure sounds like the starter is spinning like crazy and not engaging the fly wheel. Push it forward in 3rd gear as suggested, and it will probably start.



1974-1/2 Roadster, "Bumble Bee", Corvette Yellow - in shambles, wire wheels
1976 Roadster, un-named, Sandglow - "driver" condition (stock + 32/36 Weber DGEV, cast iron header, 25D distributor), bolt on wheels
james fox
Haywood, wv,, USA   usa
1979 MG MGB "Little Red Car"
I bought a '78 B that had been sitting for a few years. I drove it about 25 miles to my house. the next day I got it legal and took off, about 5 miles in it just quit. I found it was not getting gas, so I replaced the fuel filter, and it started right up. then after about30 miles or so it did the same thing. the gas tank had good gas in it but also a heck of a lot of rust. I got the tank cleaned and lined and is great now. jmo

. You can hide this ad & support this site by upgrading to a Gold Membership ~ click here for more info.
Steve5412 Avatar
Steve Wareing
Duncan B.C., Canada   can
Hi Joseph,


From the video, as previously mentioned, the starter is turning however appears not be engaging the teeth on the flywheel.
Engines typically stop at the same position and therefore when starting it is engaging the same teeth...and these become wore over time.
You can either put it in gear and push it a couple of feet or take out the spark plugs and turn the engine over by hand using a wrench on the crankshaft pulley. If the starter then engages, you know that the flywheel needs work. If so, the engine will have to be pulled.

Let's be optimistic and say that your car may well work out to be a good deal. It will certainly need a major tune-up.
Suggest checking out the local night school courses and joining an MG or British car club. Members are always helpful.

regards, Steve
Steve5412 Avatar
Steve Wareing
Duncan B.C., Canada   can
http://i642.photobucket.com/albums/uu142/walkgraham/Mini%20rebuild/questions/wornflywheelteeth.jpg

Hi Joseph, Here is a photo of a flywheel with worn teeth. You will notice that the teeth looked chipped on this side. This is the point were your starter is trying to engage but can't "bite" on the now worn teeth and therefore it just spins.

Did you turn the engine and attempt to start?

regards, Steve

joseph mandra
la grange park, USA   usa
sorry about the lack of updated but because my limited amount of car knowledge, basic tasks take me a bit longer than normal. i took the starter off and the teeth are fine on it, the flywheel however is very bad. i found out that the reason for this is probably because my buddy used a screw that was half the size of the hole to secure the top part of the starter. i was told that this probably allowed the starter to bounce around when it was engaged, basically beating the hell outta the teeth on the flywheel. but anyway here's my next question........where can i get a good deal on a new flywheel?
dickmoritz Avatar
Dick Moritz
Philly 'burbs, PA, USA   usa
Joseph,

Please check your Private Messages...

Dick



Errabundi Saepe, Semper Certi
(Often wrong, but always certain)

joneo54 Avatar
John O'Mara
metuchen, NJ, USA   usa
1964 Ford Galaxie "Battlestar Galactica"
1966 Ford E-Series "Nellie Belle"
1974 MG MGB
1978 Triumph MC Bonneville
1999 Ford Taurus "SHO_NUFF"
If you're concerned that the flywheel may be missing teeth in one spot, just leave car in gear with key off and push it back a foot or so. That will move the ring gear to a spot that hopefully has teeth and if thats the issue the starter should engage. I'll second the fuel filter check. Doesn't take much to plug it up. I switched to the clear glass type with the replaceable filter element. Makes it so much easier to see when filter needs servicing.
Steve5412 Avatar
Steve Wareing
Duncan B.C., Canada   can
Hello again Joseph,

Having determined that some of the flywheel's teeth are badly damaged, the flywheel will have to be removed and taken to a local machine shop for both a new ring and also to have it re-surfaced. This entails removing both the engine and gearbox.
At the same time, the clutch components and various seals should be examined and replaced as required. Given that the starter motor has been used several times in trying to start your car, this to will have to be checked for damage.

I would say for two guys with some experience and the correct tools (including an engine hoist) this is
a 2 -3 day job plus the time the machine shop needs. Essentially, all components including hoses, wires, radiator...anything that is connected to either the engine or gearbox will have to be removed and, of course, re-installed.

My feeling is that this may well be beyond your capability at the present time. Do you know anyone who is willing to assist you? It's not a complicated job....just a lot of work and really does need two people especially with the removal and reinstalled of the engine and gearbox.

Hope this helps. I am sure others will forward helpful advise.

regards, Steve

arkay Avatar
Ronn Kilby
El Cajon CA, USA   usa
1979 MG MGB "Sabrina"
2004 Harley-Davidson Dyna
As I said previously, buy tools, plan to learn, forum is a great resource - and good luck!
Oh- and keep us informed on your progress. Especially pictures.
bawest47232 Avatar
bruce west
houston, tx, USA   usa
1980 MG MGB "Maggie"
Haynes manual - cheap investment.

If the flywheel is bad in one spot, can't he manually turn the engine over a quarter turn with the nut on the crankshaft. Then try to start it again and see if it turns?

bawest47232 Avatar
bruce west
houston, tx, USA   usa
1980 MG MGB "Maggie"
Oh... by the way, you can use search at the top of the forum to search for your symptoms. These cars have been around for awhile - as has this forum. Many issues have been resolved in the past by previous questions....

For example, last month, someone asked a similar question to yours - there is more information or possibilities to try.

http://www.mgexperience.net/phorum/read.php?1,2001079,2001079#msg-2001079
bawest47232 Avatar
bruce west
houston, tx, USA   usa
1980 MG MGB "Maggie"
I also don't hear the click that I usually get when I try to start mine. The starter should push the drive forward to engage. It doesn't sound like it is doing this.

Nigel Peart
Kent, United Kingdom   gbr
That grating sound is the toothed pinion moving forward and grinding against teeth on the ring-gear.
These ring-gear teeth are probably worn, as are the teeth on the pinion.

Your only sensible route is to pull the engine,replace the ring-gear and starter pinion.
The actual starter motor sounds like it's working fine as it's spinning when energised.
As for the dash switches,an auto electrician should be able to de-mod and put back to
standard.

Your engine running issues have nothing to do with the above advice. Carbs are prone to collecting
grit which blocks the small holes which aid slow-running/idleing. Good fuel filtering is essential.as is a clean fuel tank. Sometimes a 40 year old fuel tank can collect an inch of dirt/sediment/muck in the bottom.


Hope this helps.
Steve5412 Avatar
Steve Wareing
Duncan B.C., Canada   can
Hello again Joseph,

From all the previous posts you will be aware that the engine and gearbox will need to be pulled. You could actually still drive your car if you can always park on a hill by switching the ignition on and releasing the handbrake. Once moving, placing it in 2nd gear and slowly let the clutch out. This is of course not very practical.

So, do you know anyone knowledgeable in order to assist you pull the engine? There is actually no way around this.
The switches etc. can wait. It's better to focus on one thing at a time. To take your car into a garage and have a mechanic pull the engine will no doubt cost more that your original purchase price of the car.

Good luck.

Steve

HuckFinn Avatar
Tammy U
Hell's Canyon, USA   usa
Removing a starter ain't Rocket Science! Takes a few bolts, a little gumption and if possible, someone to help. The help is not so important for taking it off as much as it is putting it back on (starters can be heavy and since they have to line up and the access isn't so open, two is better than one.) The local auto parts store (I find NAPA has more parts than the other one near me) can pretty much match the starter. There is a core charge, so don't throw away the old one. I would say a beginner can accomplish this task in about 20 minutes: That includes "What wrench do I need, socket? Metric or English?" and any cursing involved! :-) Not included is the trip to the auto parts store. Good luck!


The first picture is of the starter from the top of the engine. You can see the distributor cap (plug caps and wires coming out of it) at 11 o'clock (from the center of the picture.) The starter is at about 1 o'clock and is silver (right) and black (left). Part of the black side is obscured. As you can easily see from this angle, getting it in there is the most difficult part. I think I remember using an extension on the ratchet because there was some obstruction. The other bolts have to be accessed from the bottom of the engine, so make sure you've got a good, solid jack.

The second picture is of the starter, but it is a close-up. You can see the top bolt. It would be about 9 o'clock from the center, and is silver and black. Still obscured. The whole assembly weighs about 20 pounds.



HuckFinn...Free & breezy
Attachments:
MGB Starter.jpg (8.4 KB) –
MGB Starter.jpg
MGB Starter closeup.jpg (7.9 KB) –
Please Sign In or Register to view additional attachments.
HuckFinn Avatar
Tammy U
Hell's Canyon, USA   usa
Oh my friend, you'll learn more about fixing cars than you ever thought you would! Just remember, take a deep breath, smile and shake your head on the days things go awry. Owning an MG provides for an excellent education in internal combustion engines and all of the tricks needed to keep them running... :-)



HuckFinn...Free & breezy

Add your reply here, or post your own questions!

Members Sign In if you've already registered, or
Register a New Account
Registration is free and takes less than a minute

Having trouble posting or changing forum settings?
Check the Forum Help File (FAQ) or contact the webmaster.
View the archived version of this thread.
Built using Phorum Open Source Software


Join Our Club

Sign In to post questions or share your photos!

MGExp Menu

Welcome

Forums ->

MGB & GT

MG Midget

Buy, Sell & Trade

Vendor & Group Buy

MG Engine Swaps

Original MG

MGA

MGC

MG Magnette

1100 & 1300

T-Series & Prewar

Modern MGs

MG Motorsports

MG-2013 Event

Member Meetup

Other Vehicles

Off Topic

Clubs

Forum Search

Latest Posts

Journals

Calendar

Membership

Tech Library

Car Registry

Cars For Sale

Model Info

Motorsport

Directory

Member Map

MGExp Store

Search

Advertising Info

Smartphone quick link
mgexp.mobi

Adjust Text Size

Larger Smaller
Reset Save